The clue
detected by Mariner 9, according to
Gil Levin, was that the level of the gas, carbon dioxide (CO2), was
so high, according to the Mariner 9
instruments, that it could not be maintained at such a level, unless
continuously replenished by a chemical source on Mars. Levin suggested that the chemical source
might be life –not animal life but perhaps single-celled life forms, similar to
Earth’s bacteria.
But other
investigators had a different explanation:
perhaps a simple chemical that was not organic –something like hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)–
was present in the atmosphere and at work converting organic material
into CO2, thus imitating
the effects of living chemical activity that scientists call metabolism. Specifically, the chemical activity wherein
organic matter is converted to CO2 is known as oxidation and indeed it
is a process that occurs through both living and non-living phenomena. The opposite of oxidation is called reduction,
a process that we shall discuss later in connection with the Viking mission.
A
problem with the H2O2 hypothesis was that Mariner 9 detected neither H2O2
nor any other oxidizing agent in the atmosphere. The question of life on Mars was still open and would require a
more aggressive search, with instruments designed for the direct detection of
microorganisms.